The Carnegie Club

We were looking for an authentic cigar lounge with a good whiskey menu and Carnegie Club did not disappoint! We spent a wonderful Friday night here and will for sure come back! The atmosphere was fantastic, the service great and there was even some amazing live music. The food to share was just amazing: we had a nice (very big) meat platter and some flatbread with hummus, so good!It was my first time smoking a cigar and since I told that to the very kind waitress, she explained me everything I needed to know, which was very helpful. I felt a little conscious to tell her at first but she was so friendly and open that I had no doubt I didn’t need to be embarrassed telling her. She offered to help pick the cigars too and was overall very nice and provided exceptional service.What we also liked very much was the wide variety of whisky options and the overall menu.

The club has a luxurious atmosphere and well equipped staff. There is a vast selection of cigars to choose from. I had a great time. My only qualm is they do not answer the phone and I was called back about a question hours after my reservation.

My favorite place in NYC. I’ve been coming here for a few years, back when the place used to be packed with an older crowd. Within the last few months, TikTok has brought in the younger generations and the only downside is that reservation spots go super quick now! I’m glad people are catching on because this place is truly one of a kind; I haven’t found another jazz club quite like it. The Carnegie Club truly encapsulates old New York. The drinks and cigar selection are the cherry on top. Please never stop Sinatra Saturdays!

We had been eyeing Carnegie Club for a while and finally got to go for New Years Eve. We booked in advance to ensure we got a table.The club is beautiful decorated and feels like you are transported in time. They have a coat check when you walk in, super helpful on messy rainy days (like NYE).For NYE there was a $60 cover charge and a band playing rat pack hits all evening.We were so lucky to be seated upstairs on a plush couch with a direct view of the band. The couch was super comfortable. The couch had two small tables in front of it to place our drinks, food, cigars, etc.Carnegie Club has a few small plates to get if you are hungry, a cocktail menu, extensive liquor menu and an extensive cigar menu.We had the truffle popcorn and cheese plate to eat. The cheese plate is huge and comes with full, large pieces of cheese plus grapes and fig spread with crackers.I had a gin & tonic plus the raspberry fizz drink. Both were refreshing.My husband had two of their old fashioneds. He said they were strong!My husband smoked both of their house cigars at $20 each. I did not smoke. He liked the Maduro house cigar more so than the Connecticut house cigar.Despite the cigar smoke all over, I dont feel like the club was suffocating with it. You still felt like you could breathe. The smell wasnt bad either. I did come up with my clothes smelling of it slightly, but thats to be expected. Initially I was nervous I wouldnt last the whole night with the cigar smoke. I did just fine and I have a sensitive nose.The stand out of the evening was the service. The service was impeccable. Our server was always around and extremely attentive. Every one was working so hard to make sure we were all having a great time.Part of the NYE festivities included a champagne toast at midnight, noise makers, hats and a plate of small dessert cookies.They put the countdown on the TVs and the whole place did the countdown together. It was really a fun, special evening.We will remember this NYE for years to come, and are thinking of making this a yearly tradition now on NYE, since we did have so much fun.I feel extremely lucky we had good seats, some of the other seats in the place dont seem to have as good visibility to the band. The earlier you get there, the better chance you have at a good seat.Carnegie Club was the epitome of class, elegance and great service on NYE. Everything was perfect from the food, to the drinks, to the cigars, to the whole vibe.Id like to come back for a Sinatra Saturday (a Sinatra tribute band plays every Saturday) very soon!

It was a great place to enjoy some cigars and drinks. Kudos to the barwoman, who mixed two delicious Fitzgeralds, even with them not being on the menu! Will surely visit again!

Great cigar lounge!! Came here randomly with friends Friday late night—luckily there was a table available and they had a live band playing music! It has a pretty cool ambiance here.They let you smoke your own cigars, but they do have a huge selection of cigars as well. The mojitos were decent. Our server was great—friendly and attentive. Would definitely come back!

I’ve been coming here for many years and my favorite place in NYC to enjoy a cigar and a whiskey in an environment that takes you back.Comfy seating, book-lined walls, great cigar selection and well stocked bar.Considering everyone is smoking the air quality is surprisingly good thanks to the ventilation and filtration.Greek sliders hit the spot after a few drinks.

Amazing space and ambience. Had the chance to see the Saturday Sinatra show and it was amazing.

Places like this don’t exist anymore in NYC or the world for that matter. The place is amazingly built, amazing cigars and drinks. Service is top notch the GM Scott doesn’t an Amazing job at running the place. The Sinatra show is a must if you can get reservations!!!

1st time here at the CARNEGIE CLUB, and wow, we were not disappointed. You can bring your own cigars, whaaaaaaaaat?!! What other place allows you to do that. You can also purchase cigars if youd like, so cigarette smoking is also allowed in here. I noticed that after the music stops, a lot of people leave. Definitely check it out!

I had the pleasure of visiting Carnegie Club recently, and it was an unforgettable experience! The ambiance is classy and sophisticated, perfect for enjoying a night out. The selection of drinks is impressive, especially the extensive whiskey collection.I enjoyed their signature cocktails, and each one was expertly crafted and delicious. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, making excellent recommendations that enhanced my visit.What I loved most was the relaxed, sophisticated vibe, complete with live jazz music that added to the overall charm of the place. If you’re looking for a stylish spot to unwind, I highly recommend Carnegie Club!

Great atmosphere. One of the only places you can a cigar or cigarette indoors. Good service. Good variety of drinks and food.

Incredible little smoke club makes you feel like a billionaire. Great selection of stogies and a massive selection of various spirits to accompany your smoking experience. Wonderful staff who are very friendly and polite. Wished I had this back home in my part of the state. If I ever come back to Manhattan I think Ill just live here and smoke cigars the whole time. Def worth a stop and have to get the Carnegie punch, its amazingly delicious

Pretty cool place to sit and chill. You can bring your own cigar they will charge you 15$ for that. My cocktail was not tasty.

Best Cigar Bar Ive ever visited. Something for everyone here. Cigar selection is a little limited but broad. They didnt have the Cognac I wanted but i thoroughly enjoyed what the waitress brought instead. Ambience was very impressive. Service was great. Thoroughly enjoyed myself.

Very nice spot for a casual and laid back date night. The service was very good. Drinks well made. The small plates were delicious. I recommend the prosciutto flatbread. We also had the Greek sliders. They even had live jazz music. Very much enjoyed myself and would go back.

Another exceptional show at the Carnegie Club!We made reservations for back to back shows, as we always do, for Steven Maglio and were able to sit in our usual seats.As always the crowd was shifting around considerably in the club so we had to wait longer than usual in order to get drinks and cigars ordered. I usually prefer the Oban 14 year accompanied by a Winston Churchill.The staff are wonderful, they literally handle everything without missing a heartbeat. At this point its time to sit back and enjoy the show.Steve is absolutely phenomenal, highly talented and a great guy. We had a wonderful time once again, had great conversation with Steve followed by photos. This club is an absolute gem!Cheers!

Fabulous, cozy atmosphere and a nice menu of small plates. The house cigars didnt impress us because of the hints of grass and hay, but everything else did. Excellent service. Definitely a cigar lounge not to be missed while youre in NYC! I look forward to seeing the Friday or Saturday night Sinatra show when we come back!

Marvellous place, with a fantastic singer, wonderful band and great service! We went on a Saturday night for the 8 oclock Sinatra night show and stayed until closing at 2:00am this is how much we loved it! The appetizers were good, the drinks were delish and the most fantastic part was that you can smoke your own cigarettes and cigars! They also have a great selection of cigars if you decide to purchase from them! Yes it did have smoke but it is a cigar bar not sure what people expect, in-fact my husband (a cigar smoker) and i (a cigarette smoker) were discussing when we left, that we loved that it was not too smoked up! I would be here every weekend if i had the time for it! Fabulous atmosphere, with old New York vibes, l highly recommend this place if you enjoy jazz music and a good cigar/cigarette! Jeff was our server, he was one of a kind! We will be back!

Whenever I visit New York, I always make time to have a cigar and cocktail here. You should definitely try Midnight Manhattan cocktail. The prices are reasonable for this kind of place in the middle of Manhattan. There is a tobacco fee if you bring your own cigar but it’s worth it.

Best atmosphere for cigars in the city. Like walking into the Great Gatsby.

One of the few places left to smoke and drink in NYC. Cozy upscale atmosphere and friendly staff. Live music Friday-Sunday evenings. Sinatra Saturdays; $40 with two drink minimum, $50 for premium seating (2 sets usually @ 8pm & 10pm). My personal drink choices; barrel-aged old fashioned, Carnegie Punch or Angel’s Envy bourbon. Wide cigar choice on-site or BYOC ($10 cut fee unless purchased @ Davidoff or Nat Sherman).

This cigar bar exudes sophistication and charm, offering a luxurious retreat for cigar aficionados. As you step inside, the rich aroma of fine cigars fills the air, creating an inviting atmosphere for guests to unwind and indulge in their favorite smokes. The well-stocked humidor showcases a diverse selection of premium cigars, catering to both seasoned connoisseurs and novices alike. The knowledgeable staff is on hand to provide recommendations and expert advice, ensuring a memorable experience for all visitors. The elegant decor, comfortable seating, and dim lighting set the perfect ambiance for relaxation and socializing. Whether youre looking to enjoy a solo smoke or gather with friends over drinks, this cigar bar provides a refined setting for an evening of indulgence and camaraderie.

Great night, ambiance was good....live band. Drinks and cigars are on the pricier side, but they do offer a package deal. Shout out to my man Carter AKA Young Yacht for the launch of Mogul Cigars

This place is seriously one of my favorite places Ive visited in NYC as someone who has been here 8-9 times. First, we tried getting a reservation for about a month and decided to test our luck by showing up and seeing if anyone was a no show. Luckily for us, a guy was giving up his spot right before the Sinatra Saturday show started. The show was absolutely amazing and we stayed for the second one. Our bartender, I think his name was Joy/Troy?, was FANTASTIC. Incredibly nice and quick to serve everybodys drinks. Couldnt have asked for better. My only complaint is that the announcer specifically said to keep conversations to a minimum during the show and people continued to talk loudly throughout. At one point it was hard to hear the performer during one of my favorite songs. I understand you cant really tell people to not talk at all, but conversations should have been hushed versus yelling because of intoxication. Other than that, it was a great experience!

This is a great cigar bar with a fantastic Sinatra performance on Saturday evenings. However, the staff at the door is rude and highly disrespectful. Be prepared, even if you have a reservation on a busy evening. I have been a customer for years and never experienced such horrendously disrespectful treatment at the door until recently; how times have changed. There are other cigar bars that deliver a much higher standard for service, recommend checking those out instead.

Very cool cigar lounge..had a Old Fashioned and sat back and enjoyed the 1950s vibes...Im not a smoker and I did find the cigar smoke slightly bothersome but hey I knew it was gonna be smokey...would def go back next time Im in NYC

Classic. Its a very nice cigar lounge. Better do reservation to get a sofa seat

What a great night!

The look and feel of this cigar lounge is exactly what you expect. Its a nice relaxing vibe with great prices on cigars and some nice cocktails.Service was average (I get the difficulty of giving a great service when people are smoking and chatting right there), cocktails were tasty.Overall a great place to sit for a smoke and a drink in NYC.

Do not let the “rules” scare you off. The dress code is a joke. We had guys at the next table wearing tshirts and backward ball caps, a guy across from us wearing a Yankees ball cap and elsewhere were people who looked like they had just removed their judicial robes before stepping in the door. Athletic shoes were the norm, not the exception. And I had a most enjoyable evening, other than the guy sitting next to us screaming, yes screaming, into his phone. For God’s sake folks either text or call her outside. We do not need to know your business.They were out of my first two choices of sticks, but even the third choice was a premium smoke, so no complaints there. The drinks were quite good, the wait staff was excellent and the manager stopped by the table. My wife was one of three women in the club who did not work there. The ventilation system was average for a cigar lounge. In other words, it was pretty damned smokey in there. Which I expect, regardless of how great a cigar bar says their ventilation system is.I bought a nice lighter as a souvenir. Overall I give it four stars only because of the ferocity of the stated dress code and the obvious lack of enforcement of the same. Decorum is the hallmark of a great club. Either drop the code or enforce it. At least tell them to take off their ball caps.

Someone overheard me asking my wife to google search a spot where I could get a cigar and this place was recommended and not very far from the restaurant we were at. It was exactly what I was looking for. A great selection of wines for my wife and a great selection of beer and cigars for me. I personally do a dark stout paired with a cohiba blue and it was the perfect ending to my birthday dinner. A couple of large TV’s with sports (NBA) on and a great atmosphere for conversation. Perfect spot for a night cap or just a place to hang out. Very friendly hostess who greeted us immediately as we walked in and were taken to a section to sit, with no wait. There was also an upstairs area that was a bit more private but we like to be in the mix. Great spot! And our waitress was very helpful as well. Would definitely go back.

I am from Miami, where we have the best cigar lounges with great atmosphere, service, and the best cigars. I came to NYC on vacation and tried visiting this lounge twice. Both times, it was closed for private events. No prior notice or announcement online. Tried calling, but no one answered the phone. You should care more about new customers because that is how you get new service and future recommendations. The door man doesn’t even allow you to step foot inside. I will never visit this place again and don’t recommend. If you are in NYC and want to have a cigar, go to Macanudo Cigar Club. Nice selection, nice place. and nice service.

TLDR liked the unique experience and atmosphere but had some gripesWent for Sinatra Saturdays. The 8:00pm show doesn’t feature popular songs like New York New York or My Way, which are instead hinted to be part of the 10:30pm show, for which an additional charge applies, which felt a bit like an upsell.We had good seats above the bar but couldn’t actually see the band hidden at the front of the location, nor properly hear some of the introductory anecdotes.Lastly on the website it states that the tobacco fee is waived on Saturdays, but you can still expect a very smoky atmosphere.

Atmosphere at this place is unmatched. Awesome cigar bar, great drinks.

The truffle popcorn was surprisingly not super truffle-y and the air was surprisingly clean with just a scent of cigar.

This is a must-see, must go to type cigar lounge! Weve gone here 3 times since finding it! The atmosphere is beautifully decorated, the drinks were amazing, and theres always nice tunes playing. What I love love is that ur not overwhelmed with smoke! They have to have a very good ventilation system. I will definitely visit here again!

An iconic institution for cigars. Nice old world charm. Great leather sofas. What I like is the super user friendly cigar menu. They even have a description about each cigar in the menu. Gaby, our hostess was super attentive as well as knowledgeable about cigars.She also gave her recommendations on cigars and that too by just being a passive smoker. 😎😎. Highly recommended place for anyone who loves cigars

It breaks my heart that I cant give this place MORE than 5 stars!This. Place. Is. Amazing!!!!!!Great service, incredible drink options and cigar selections.Christian is amazing!!! Plus, great at dancing and yoga!

Wonderful night at Carnegie Club last night. Great servers and staff. Cozy accommodations for our party of 7. Excellent cigar selections, great scotch, and of course 10/10 music. Definitely will be back!

Ive been here before when there was no show and it was a good time and nice place to smoke. The drinks were good, but if youre hungry order the cheese platter. You get some great cheeses and plenty of them. The Frank Sinatra show was great. If you want the really popular Sinatra songs go to the second show. But you arent losing out. Also, the $40 tickets you could end up anywhere on there and with an obstructed view. Choose wisely as to what matters.

Upscale Cigar lounge. Cigar Menu and Drinks Menu. You don’t have the choice to choose like when you are in a humidor. This is a cigar menu and all the options are pricey. Choose your cigar carefully because if not you are going to end up with a cigar you don’t enjoy as much

Wonderful environment with a relaxed ambiance with soothing music playing. The air filtration is amazing with very little noise and balanced conditioning. Menu Variety is plentiful, with a large variety of Cigars for all levels of smokers.

Waitress lit the wrong cigars (we ordered davidoff, she brought out other cheaper ones by accident) and then proceeded to give us the pitch on the cheaper cigars and why we should continue to smoke them vs correcting her mistake. We were celebrating, only smoke cigars 3-4 times a year, and wanted the davidoff but stayed with the other cigar bc it felt like she would have had to pay for the wrongly lit ones.

A great bar and cigar place.During the weekend with nighty shows.

The Carnegie Club is a very nice place to enjoy friends and meet new people. Cigars are the central theme, so if you dont enjoy cigars or dont want to smell like a cigar when you leave, this is not your place.If you are interested in enjoying craft drinks and a cigar, The Carnegie Club should be on your list.

The Carnegie Club is the epitome of old-school New York cool. Sitting at the bar, in Carnegie Hall, puffing on cigars, sipping port—its like stepping into a Rat Pack movie. Sincere thanks to the bartender for hooking me up with a gentle cigar that has only left me with the best memories the day after. The vibe inside is just luxe. Such a cool night.

The server was excellent, the ambience was so cool and the toasted marshmallow old-fashioned was superb. Ill return again upon my next visit

Sinatra Saturday is a must go! We had booked a table roughly 2 months in advance, I thought thats a little too long to wait for a night out, but boy was it worth it! We got tickets for the early show and loved the experience so much that we decided to stay for the late show as well. The club accomodated our last minute decision and we even got to keep our table which was amazing. The Stan Rubin Orchestra was fantastic and Steve Maglio waz amazing. Performance was stunning, with subtle jokes and short stories about Sinatra, truly an amazing experience. Steve definitely know how to entertain and was a crowd pleaser. Not a Sinatra impersonator, but a Sinatra lover and a good singer. Food was fantastic, we ordered a few platters and everything was delicious. Cocktails were well crafted, I had a classic old fashioned and was not dissappointed. Our server Jeff was great and catered to all our needs. I definitely would recommend this place to all Sinatra lovers, jazz lovers and cigar afficionados. Cant wait to our next visit.EDIT: Visited again on a Friday night and once again had a great time. This time it was not a Sinatra night and a different band was playing, but it was just as much fun. We made a reservation abt a week in advance, arrived on time and were sitted promptly. Service was once again great, the band was pretty good and the cherry on top was a singer that just stopped for a couple of songs to sing with them, but he was sooo good, that made the experience so much better. Very smooth, mellow voice. We would be back soon, that is for sure. 5/5

An absolutely incredible place. We stumbled upon this place the first time I visited NYC and just had to have a proper visit. The staff are amazing and I would highly recommend Sinatra Saturdays. Do not hesitate to book a table. You have the finest Scotch and Brandy to choose from here, as well as an extensive cigar menu. Did I mention, you can smoke inside this place. Dress to impress and croon the night away.

What a fabulous place. Excellent cigar choices. Generous cheese board. Nice wine choices. Best part, the decor is dark and intimate. The music volume is perfect.

Had a great time...music Friday evening was fantastic

Warm and upscale cigar lounge on two levels with craft cocktails. The atmosphere is like a gentlemans library, perfectly suitable for solo guys, pairs, or small groups, probably not a good fit for rowdy bachelor parties. I was impressed by the smooth and attentive service and the thoughtfully curated cigar choices. Theyve gone for quality over quantity. There is a small food menu for things like charcuterie boards and similar items.

Beautiful place with awesome service and cigars

Their website let us go ahead and book to see Frank Sinatra tribute show for 8 oclock. It even asked us to select the 8 oclock show or the 10..30 show .We bought new jackets to fit the required dress code .We arrived all excited ..but theres NO Frank Sinatra show at all . ..and we recieved no gift as compensation .However its a beautiful building !

If youre a cigar smoker this is the place to be. Fantastic atmosphere. Live old-school jazz band playing some great tunes. Amazing selection of cigars and liquors. Prices might be a little high but theres no cover.Will be coming back for sure!

Embarrassing as an establishment to even offer a seat ON THE STAIRCASE to someone who reserved months in advance. Staff was unhelpful and frankly extremely rude. Left before even placing an order. I will never attend here again and I advise anyone looking at booking here to strongly consider booking elsewhere. Would give 0 stars if I could.

Sinatra Saturday was incredible. Absolutely brilliant performance by all. Can’t wait to go back!!

Absolutely beautiful atmosphere. Great bar service. If you love cigars, its a must visit and cant be beat.

This place has a presence about it. You feel special the second you walk in the doors. I thoroughly enjoyed myself.Of course the cigars and drinks are marked up but what would you expect. You are paying for the ambience. I mean I felt under dressed by not having on a sports jacket.The bartender was just lovely. She told some great stories. Lets get her more money. Next time I come back Ill be sure to catch the show.

The atmosphere here is one of a kind! Reminiscent of a time long gone. The drinks are amazing and the cigar options are plenty.

Outstanding and beautifully paneled cigar lounge in midtown Manhattan. Cigar selection is surprisingly larger than I expected. My first choice was out of stock but my second, third and fourth choices were available 😉. Drink menu has enough variety to please many pallettes.

Not too many cigar bars left in NYC. This is one of the best in terms of ventilation system and old-school atmosphere. Slot of old timer Zoot-Suit and the jazz music is a great extra touch. Be ready to spend some cash, but worth the it.

Good cigars and service. Whiskey selection is respectable. A bit overpriced but youre paying for ambiance. Worth it for special occasions.

Called to ask a question, was put on hold for over an hour (proof attached). Tried calling from different numbers and no one picked up, straight to voicemail.

Have been coming here for years, the Carnegie Club is one of the best spots in NYC to have a cigar. Sinatra night on Saturdays is a must do!

Best cigar club ive ever been. I dont think anything can beat this place. Best thing of all is the house blend cigar made by Oliva.

My wife took me to Sinatra Saturday for my birthday. I wouldnt really say I was a Sinatra fan, but the whole experience was absolutely amazing. The orchestra with the atmosphere, a nice cigar, and a glass of scotch is a match made in heaven. I travel a lot and this has to be my favorite place Ive been to!

A great lounge to stop in if you’re in Manhattan. Old school with a little bit of speakeasy feel. Comfortable seating and great ventilation . Good cigar selection, and spirits to go with. Highly recommend that you stop by.

What can I say about this Iconic location. The music is fantastic. The shows warm your soul. The staff is warm and friendly and knowledgeable about both the drinks they serve and the cigars they offer, which, if you are an aficionado about both, like me, is a huge plus when I want to pair a 55 Robusto and a fine Cognac. It is always a favorite place for me and love to return often with clients after a sporting or entertainment event or just to sit back and relax solo style. Look for me there, long hair entertainment attorney, tapping a foot to the music, puffing away.

My husbands favorite visit while in the city. I tag along and enjoy their fabulous drinks and atmosphere.

This place is such a vibe I came here on a Sunday we brought our own cigars, ordered a few drinks, laughed listening to some jazz music I will definitely be coming back!

My absolute favorite place in NYC. Fantastic lounge to relax and enjoy good drinks and cigars. Love it here, wish I could go more often. Great service. Food menu is limited but thats okay since food isnt really their specialty.

I was in the city with my wife on vacation and it was a rainy day. So glad I found a great place to stay dry and relax. Very nice place to have a great cigar and classic Old Fashioned while my wife read her book. Highly recommend the service and atmosphere are top notch.

I spent a fantastic evening here for my birthday. With a selection of whiskeys and cigars to go with the talented jazz band, it was beyond relaxing. Do note that many people will be smoking, so keep that in mind when planning a trip.

Great place right by Carnegie Hall to duck in for a quiet, relaxing smoke in the afternoon and at night out too. Attentive and welcoming staff. Great ventilation. The modest $15 cutting fee makes it even more conducive to bringing your own stick. Like I did.

The prices of the cigars is laughable. $42 for a Melanio lol, I can get those for $8 online.

This cigar club is open to the public but feels like an elegant private club that has been in situ for many a decade. The cocktails ($17) are ok priced for the location but the quality and service make them a great deal. We split a cheese platter to nibble on and it was generous with a good variety of cheese. We brought our in cigars and paid the $10 cutting fee so the evening was a bargain!

Wasted an entire night on my wife’s birthday coming from NJ because she picked this place that does not advertise that it’s a CIGAR BAR!! The air is unbearable !! If you’re not into smoking this place is NOT for you!!

The only thing we did not like is the coctails . They were realy bad but the food is good service is good and the atmosphere is good just order whisky not coctails.

Elegant, classy, fun place to hang out. Dont expect the smoke to clear out, great place to take a lady if she really loves you and can handle lots and lots of smoke. Get there early for Saturdays with Sinatra and call ahead to make a reservation - highly recommended. If you show up late you may not get in. Expect a cover some nights in addition to a tobacco and alcohol minimum on Sinatra nights ($40/pp + $20/pp minimum) well worth it though the band is awesome the singer is amazing. Booze and cigars a very very pricey - regular Zacapa about $16, Padron 1964 Maduro Diplomatico is $44 but there is no place with this atmosphere especially on Sinatra night.

Great music and atmosphere. Best place to enjoy a cigar and Scotch drink.

Excellence of NYC. What a fantastic crowd. Very relaxed intimate setting if your company can bare the smokers.. Not bad, as they have proper ventilation and air scrubbersFood options are limited but they have a good selection and presentation for such a venue.

Place is a classy cigar bar with a lot of space and the staff is pretty attentive if your cigar goes out. They did mess up my order a bit but it was still a good experience

Great relaxed ambiance. Service was top notch from Efrain (awesome guy/takes care of his customers) 👌 When were in ny, we will def be back!

Ambience is amazing. Staffs are so nice. You can smoke your cigar either inside or outside. But service was a little bit slow.

The place is awesome but hostess Ashley really stole the show! She gave us a reservation over the phone and it was so nice to meet her in person where the table was exactly what we wanted. A true asset to the team!

Amazing ambience, great food and great service. Make sure to get their olive & nuts, and their lamb chops.

Best cigar lounge in NYC in my opinion. I try and visit whenever I am in NYC.

We go here if Davidoff lounge is full. This club allows you to smoke cigars purchased from Davidoff and with the receipt they waive the cutting fee. Thats the great plus. But when it becomes crowded sometimes staff becomes less attentive.

I was always in love with this spot. So sexy and love the band that plays on Friday and Saturday. Always enjoyed it more than the Havana Club.

Always like this place. Very unique live shows, particularly when Steve Maglio is performing Sinatra with the eleven piece orchestra. Where can one find this on the regular? Great place for a date and a cigar.

I look forward to visiting the Carnegie Club whenever I am in NYC. The atmosphere makes it a perfect place to enjoy a great cigar and a real drink brought to you by elegant servers and prepared by experienced bartenders. An upscale New York venue worth visiting.

Place was great. Reservations are definitely recommended.

Decided to to here, as a lone female. Place was full of men and except for the serving staff, no more than 4 other women.This is one of the places in NYC Ive gone as a lone coloured/African woman and not felt any discrimination. I love it! Service was impeccable, I took the Carnegie punch and it was potent Lol! What a change from the watered down cocktails in Manhattan. I can drink lol but thia cocktail took me by surprise.The ambience was great but I did a lot of people watching since I was also alone. I wasnt rushed though the place was relatively busy. So the men seem to have a dress code of blue jeans, a shirt and dress jacket. Majority had Brown shoes and a few black. Others had sneakers which were so odd but those seemed like regulars. 2hrs and I didnt want to leave, and I was alone so I guarantee you its a great place.

The smoke is all over your clothes but service great

Nice spot for a top shelf drink and quality smokes.

Nice decent ambience and good Drinks. You can bring your own cigars. Thats the place in NY to smoke a cigar. Fully recommended!

Fantastic place to have a great evening with some great friends Service top-notch quality

Unfortunately, I did not get the hostesses name, but she was incredibly welcoming and friendly. Kristin was awesome at the bar and made me an outstanding old fashioned. Will definitely return. Hopefully sooner than later

Very comfortable. Goor atmosphere for conversation with old friends. Great sticks and whiskey. The service is top notch.

Great cigar bar. Classy and gentlemen club like. They have shows after 7 pm. Great cigar selection. If you are not a smoker, dont go there....lots of smoke

I love The Carnegie Club. Unique variety of cigar selection, fantastic atmosphere, polite and professional staff. The venue is appropriate for business or just a quiet night enjoying a cigar. Very New York.

The go-to ultimate cigar lounge experience!

This place is probably one of the very few places I know that you can smoke and drink indoors. A bit pricey but for a reason. I have always had a great time there and met really cool people.

Unique place. Best cigars and excellent burban in incredible atmosphere.

Great atmosphere and drinks! had a lovely chat with glen, the host and will definitely be back

If you like Franky (Sinatra that is) you would love Saturday nights at the Carnegie

If youre looking for a cool smoking club that has a great selection of smokes than this is your place. While it isnt as big as some of the other more popular clubs they make up for it with a cool scene and live music. 2 floors and great staff, will definitely be back.

Cigar lounge, perfect place to smoke and relax

Great chill spot to have a cigarAs a female cigar smoker i enjoy myself in the place

Whenever I visit Manhattan I stop by this cigar lounge. This time wasnt as pleasant due to poor service and rude waiter. Planning to go back to NYC in October. Hope the services and experience is better

Amazing atmosphere, old school cigar bar. The Sinatra show was superb. If you can get in go. Beyond anything I expected.

Glenn is a sweetheart and Anela made us feel so welcomed. Come on Saturday for the live Sinatra music

Great service, atmosphere, cigars and scotch!

Great place for cigars after dinner. Good staff and attentive. Obviously you get smokey. Only downside when busy difficulty in finding a place to sit

Brian is an excellent bartender, very knowledgeable drink and cigar wise. Joy was a pleasure to talk to! Great atmosphere, the perfect place to escape from the norm!

Amazing time . Today I had my first Cuban cigar along with champagne. Love the band amazing decor. I will be back next week

I cannot recommend this place enough. A slice of Old New York in mid town that is above all else classy and sophisticated. Go on a Saturday night, youll thank me later. Reservations nearly required.

Really nice ambience.

Friendly service, great food, comfortable seating.

Been here several times over the past few years, good selection of spirits, attentive staff, very nice bar, good location, has a decent selection of sticks, low to no cutting fee. Whats not to like?

Its everything I want in a cigar bar. Fine alcohol, leather furniture and friendly service. 10 dollar cutting fee if you bring your own. Might be worth it

The quintessential classy NYC experience.

Comfortable and friendly atmosphere. Their house maduro alone was worth the visit! I tried their punch too. Real sweet, but tastey. Delicious chicken pita sandwich they got for me from the Greek spot next door. Very smart way to have a kitchen!

My second time here and it is a beautiful, chill, relaxing after work cigar bar!!! Thank you to my wonderful beautiful attentive server Megan she was just plain old AWESOME ❤️

I visited the Carnage Club for a live music event, and the atmosphere was absolutely unforgettable. It’s the perfect place to wear your best evening gown and feel truly exquisite.

Where is the zero-star option. All small ring gauge stuff and horrible selection. Seedy patrons and ugly waitresses. Forget this place. Avoid at all costs. I took an Uber to Club Macanudo and never looked back.

Amazing service, really good cigars and whisky’s

Upscale place, great cigar selection, great service

Best Cigar lounge in NY!

Love it here!

Saturday Night Sinatra show is phenomenal, Steve is a great entertainer!

Nice place for cigar smokers to light up and have a drink. They have a band that is decent. Prepare to smell of smoke since the smoke extractors cannot keep up. Eat there only if you have to.

Great spot for a nice cigar

It says on website and Google that they are open till 2 a.m. but I arrived 1:30 a.m. and they very angrily told me that they are closed and didn’t even let me purchase a cigar to go

Wonderful Sinatra Night

Fantastic cigar bar! Great feel. Great service. Highly recommend.

This is a great place for a bunch of guys to hang out. Great music, great ambience and excellent service! Reminds me of the old days during the wild 80s.

Racist establishment with very discriminatory staff. Doesnt matter if you pay your ticket they will sit you on the back. Great selection of cigars and drinks but not worth the mistreatment.

The quality of cigars they stock somewhat varies depending on how long it has been there before you get one. A safe option would be going for the most famous one like Cohiba, which is thus less likely to have been stowed down there for long. Bartenders and staffs are friendly and very professional at helping you get the right whiskies, cocktails, and cigars. On Friday nights or weekends you may be requested to move your seat, or even to leave in worse cases, unless you made a reservation in advance.

Awesome environment. My gosh the orchestra playing frank sinatra, great location. And yes very upscale and expensive. But worth it..

What an experience! Great atmosphere, hospitality was great and staff is super friendly and fast too. Smoke was great, drinks even better!

The scenery was great, The service was terrible. No one came to offer drink service nor cigars. This was a real disappointment.

Its one of those old school place where you can come after work and unwind with a tasty cigar and smokey whiskey. Service is always impeccable; makes you feel important.

A perfect place to smoke and drink, but the food is the worst and so gross. Dont order food over here.

Simply a perfect cigar lounge, got the ol timey feel with all the wood and books, great selection of cigars and single malts

If you live cigars (which I do), great music, and old Hollywood decor...GO! This place wont disappoint!

Expensive but cool ambiance and good drinks/cigars

Classy atmosphere for smoking cigars. Theres a purchase minimum, of which a part has to be tobacco.

Amazing hidden spot. Service is amazing. Great selection of cigars and drinks

Im from colombia and i went Sinatra Saturday and this place is pretty amazing. I recommend it for 100% to listen wonderful jazz.

Sinatra Saturdays at The Carnegie Club deserve 8 out of 5 stars!

Not the best cigar selection. However just having the option to smoke is always nice.

Classic Cigar Lounge. Saturday Sinatra was very well done. Excellent scotch list, as well as cigars.

Amazing time away the Carnegie club. Show was fantastic, and the service was great as well. A must if your visiting NYC

Great place old school classic people

I was lucky enough to be able to visit the Carnegie Club on a Sinatra Saturday, where Steven Maglio performs. They get booked very quickly so they recommend booking 60 days in advance. I only came across this place the previous night, I left them a message, and luckily they managed to squeeze us in. It was a fully booked, and I can understand why. The atmosphere was amazing from the second we entered. Hospitality was friendly, but professional, great selection of drinks and food. Steven Maglios performance was amazing, and made us understand why on Saturdays like this it is so difficult to get a table. Next time I visit New York, Ill be definitely back!

Great feeling place. Smoke a cigar, sip your choice of beverage. Listen to great music.Make a reservation!

Great ambience, great cigar selection, wonderful smooth jazz in the background - speakeasy life!

The Frank Sinatra show with Steven Maglio is the best show in the city

Best cigar bar, great ambiance, live music, and awesome spirits! Great crowd and very good service over all.

Ive never had such a terrible experience. The waitstaff was rushing everyone, yelling that if we did not make our assigned time within 10 minutes they would give our table away. the security guard yelled at me not to walk in front of the stage. the waitstaff didnt even have cigar cutters. they were massively understaffed so wait times were super long. then on top of that they tried to kick us out of our table almost immediately after the set finished. I could not believe how terrible the service was. I used to be a regular when I lived in NYC but I will never come back here again and urge all other guests to stay away. 0 stars

A great bar that has great cigars, drinks and a selection of food. Great, friendly staff that comes and cuts and lights your first cigar. You can bring your own cigars but recommend to pick up at least from the club. Also open late which is a great plus!!

You will literally feel like your in an Italian mob movie when you walk in. It was pretty awesome. Very pricey, but it was fun.

Beautiful and cosy place! Still no Cuban cigars on sale but you can bring yours (10usd charge). Great anyway!

Remember when you could smoke in bars? Youll come out of this place with lung cancer and a sick dry cleaning bill.

Great place for a smoke cocktail and a show on Saturday night, great service comfy seats, highly recommended, a good cigar menu

It’s always an amazing time. Steven Maglio show is incredible. Jose the security guard is very nice and so is Aaron the Manager. They accommodated us even though they were packed.

Awesome Place awesome selection of cigars get the padron 40th anniversary you only live once

Great place. Really comfortable, great service. Fantastic selection of bourbon and tequila.

Great spot in the city to enjoy a smoke, enjoy live music and have a great drink. Looking forward to visiting again.

Very nice looking place and feel like if i wasnt turned away i wouldve enjoyed it. Showed up at 6:30pm and was told that they already did last call. Very disappointed.

I just visited this lounge for the 1st time. I feel its alot more comfortable vs Club Macanudo. More room & not as tight. Very nice old school vibe. Service was great. EXCELLENT ventilation system. It doesnt even smell like cigars in there! I wasnt wreaking of cigar smell when I left and this place is CLEAN. Staff keeps it in great looking shape.Great experience and might be my NEW go to cigar spot vs Macanudo or Merchants.

Old school cigar bar with solid ventilation and stiff drinks. Saturday night Sinatra show with crooner Steve Maglio is a must-see NYC classic. (Smoking allowed so plan to dry clean your clothes though.)

Great place. Friendly staff. Ill be back.

Great space to meet people and have a good stick

These crooks had a tip required on top of the cover charge. Insane.

High End cigar lounge. Pricey but worth it. Friendly atmosphere!!! Will definitely return!!

Good evening guys and dollsThis is usually a phenomenal experience but this time out we were faced with some persecution. We were told over the phone that there was no cover charges because of the lack of Steve Maglio however we were charged regardless of the insistence on other patrons. We like the place but we aren’t overtly happy with the lack of consistency in the patrons word. Come by for nice times, smoking your choice cigars but be aware of additional charges no matter the lack of the proper entertainment as advertised.

It was our friends birthday, and loves this kind of atmosphere. They had cheese and crackers with wine, and the cigar were great quality. We were a group of 8 each. we split the bill at 75 per person

Wow! Cant say enough great things about this place. Very classy, but relaxed vibe. The staff was great, the cigar menu was good. My waiter cut and lit my cigar for me. If your in NYC and a cigar smoker this is the place to be!

Ambiance was great… service needs improvement. Had to ask the server several times for re lite and was not attentive

Amazing experience and service. Hope this place lives on unchanged.

Looks like a very nice place but we had to leave even before the show begins, after finding out we had the worse table ever, 0 visibility, on the corner between cigar lockers and service table.. really?!!A special mention to the hostess who was incredibly arrogant, wondering why she’s even doing this job.

Horrible service. All the glasses they brought over were stained with lip marks and had remaining orange pulp from previous drinks. When mentioned.

Friendly staff, great cigar selection 👌

Alwaya have a great experience. People are very pleasant,

Great cigar selection

Great place to unwind have a drink and smoke indoors. Food was delicious.

The drinks & sticks of happiness are 2nd to the ambiance of a real American treasure. A must experience for those seeking a true heaven.... ....

Very nice upscale smoking lounge, great music, great drinks.

My husband and I were extremely disappointed with our experience last weekend.We were excited for the Sinatra Saturdays show and expected that the $40 per person cover charge (and 2-drink minimum) would include an opportunity to watch and listen to the ensemble, as well as at least a baseline level of service.Not only were we seated in a location in the back where we could not see any part of the show—there was also a thick crowd of loud and drunk people surrounding the back of the bar where we were seated. This meant we could barely hear the show and were constantly being stepped on while seated.Also, we were NEVER checked on and had to flag down our waiter for cocktails each time we wanted to order. We asked for water three separate times and only received it toward the end of the evening when we resorted to going to the bar ourselves to ask. While we were so upset with the service and experience, we acknowledge that it is not the waiter’s fault and was more so caused by the overall lack of management of the number of people allowed into the space and the degree of their inebriation.We do not plan on returning and sincerely hope they consider improving all the factors we mentioned above. We fully believe the amount of money we spent last night DOES NOT merit the experience we received.

Our evening at the Carnagie Club took an unexpected turn when we were greeted by a hostess who claimed she was not expecting us, even though our names were on the list when we arrived. We had made this reservation as part of a special occasion and had specifically requested premium seats next to the orchestra via OpenTable. However, upon arrival, they informed us that there was no seating available in that area and offered to place us between tables, which understandably didnt sit well with the other premium guests. To make matters worse, the lady who eventually attended to us displayed incredible rudeness, when a simple apology for the misunderstanding could have sufficed. Despite these initial hiccups, its worth noting that the show, atmosphere, and the rest of the night turned out to be great!

Great Cigars! Even better ambiance!Def plan on coming back!!

Very relaxing atmosphere with spectacular service and very conveniently located. Cant wait to go back.

Stopped by on a Friday night - service was slow, the ventilation was terrible, had to sit across from and watch a very young woman grope a very old man.. waiter wasn’t helpful at all with cigar choices and just made multiple insults. Plus the cigars were hardly better than from a gas station. Drinks were decent though and had a sweet building design etc.Overall, nothing compared to a nice cigar club, but an option if you’re in need.

Good place to enjoy your Friday night

Superb Cigar Club. So good, we came here twice on our work trip. Nice selection of cigars and drinks. Laid back, great service. Very good ventilation. Its easy to have a conversation even when it gets busy. A great experience. Visited 4/2022.