Hamilton Hall Bar & Restaurant

Friends & I saw it was open and went in for a quick late dinner. It was amazing the wings, tacos , artichoke dip! The different flavors of frozen margaritas were perfect. Mickey was the best , so helpful and engaging. Definitely will be returning.

Great atmosphere. The Owner is absolutely amazing followed by great staff! Nice place to unwind after work. Perfect place for food, drinks and relaxing. Has a “Cheers” vibe… I have to say each time I came out, I left feeling fantastic! Had an event here as and it was great!*Had Brunch and dinner*

The bar is a cozy spot with a nice diverse crowd ( a mom and a baby, a guy searching for a friend, a beauty at the bar, good guys out for fun, and a random party in the back). This is the place for anyone who wants a great drink, cool people, and awesome service.When we showed up, they had added a new item. We tried it and it came out incorrectly. The manager came through and made it right and took care of us with kindness.I believe it is an Irish spot, and the attention was 100 percent comfort and care—it was hospitality first.It is a place to escape from a tumultuous day in the concrete jungle! I will be back again and again.

Our server was Shannon, and she was amazing. Really kind, helpful and was really flexible with our party. We had five of us. The food came out fast. The music was a little loud (not terribly) for the brunch-time in my opinion.

So this place is surprisingly spacious, it has a private rooms section in the back, which will be a great rental space. Decorated really nicely. But the food is a big NO. We got wings and they had the breading on it which it wasn’t my fave. We had a chicken pot pie, which tasted like a chicken soup with a flaky croissant on the side. The 3 bean nacho was great. I wanted to admit to it, which I did, and they had steak, which were burnt. The apple pie was… not good it was pretty presentation. I would just come here for drinks and to watch a game that’s about it.

Awesome food with a laid back chill atmosphere.This restaurant / pub has a very relaxing vibe with a great selection of cocktails. They also have an extensive menu to satisfy that late night cravings.I ordered their signature Hamilton burger, and its one of the best burgers I’ve had in NY. Order it and taste its righteousness. I also got the salmon with risotto that was cooked to perfection.Seriously, this place got everything you need when you pass by Broadway.

Stopped by for a quick bite. The host, server and bartender were attentive & the food was great. Definitely recommend coming here if you’re in the area.

Hamilton Hall is a great spot, located right off of Broadway in Harlem. I came in recently for the first time to have a drink and it was a great experience. Mickey is the best bartender and the atmosphere is really warm + inviting! :-) I didn’t eat, but the food looked really good. I will definitely return here, this is a great bar & restaurant!!

Solid draft list - lot of IPAs. Excellent wings and burger. Excellent neighborhood spot for just about anything. In my case, a spot at the bar with some good food!

Food is delicious. I highly recommend this place. I Been going here for months and the food never lets me down. Great music, friendly servers and drinks. A place I recommend to anyone that enjoys a fantastic atmosphere.Pan seared chicken, Brussels sprouts, and mash potatoes with bits of bacon with a Krombacher pils is my fav.

Great negronis! 1 of my favorites. I had the new curry fries and its delicious. Live jazz, dj sets and music on week ends. Cant wait for their garden to open up when the weather gets warner soon.

Best neighborhood bar and restaurant. Terrific happy hour food and drink. Love their back patio when the weather is nice. The staff and owner are very friendly.

The atmosphere I loved and the chicken sandwich was so good. The manager came and greeted me and my family he made us feel really comfortable, and I cant wait to go back

This place does nice presentation and preparation with ingredient choices That make the dish DELICIOUSNESS, ample and priced appropriately. Very Nice.

We’ve had dinner here several times. Staff is always friendly. Menu is a mix of standard bar fare and some more interesting choices, such as crispy skin salmon over spinach and risotto. There are various vegan and vegetarian options. Full bar and beer selection, including several NA beers. Lighting and ambiance are pleasant.

I was today with a friend and the waitress with only 2 days of experience give me an amazing service, I really recommend the place. The food was delicious. Its a comeback place!

Really bad service. We visited the restaurant last week for bfast and the server didn’t even say hi or good morning. I greeted her. We ordered coffees and she brought the coffee but spilled in the saucers and without even saying a word she left. I went to the counter to ask for extra napkins to clean the saucers. The coffees were good though but the food was just okay. Then after finishing our coffees and bfast we ordered cold drinks and all the plates and cutlery stayed on the table until we left. She didn’t even bother to take the empty plates and there was only one more table except us. It was highly disappointing and the overall attitude wasn’t good at all. We felt like she didn’t want to serve us. We paid the bill, gave her the tip and left. I don’t recommend going there if you don’t want to feel bad or disrespected.

Absolutely amazing spot to go to After work or Brunch Spot. Amazing staff and the manager is awesome and will answer all questions. Which I wish more bars did.

I got their meatball soup when I arrived at this Irish pub in the heights on a Sunday night. Musicians started a set of live jazz as I ate. The food was solid and the drinks were good too. I think this place is has a very cozy feel and it right next to the 145th St station.

Great spot with NFL Ticket. You can watch all the games.

Great salad, martinis, and service! Loved the cozy atmosphere

Excellent spot for birthday celebrations! I invited about twenty guests for a birthday brunch here and we all loved the service and drinks. The waiter and owner were very accommodating and went above and beyond to ensure I had a memorable birthday. I would come back here again and highly recommend sitting in the back room!

I’m a local and both love and frequent so many of the bars in the neighborhood. However, the bartender Tasha was very rude. I just came back from checking out their happy hour and she didn’t say ONE word to me, yet spoke with every other customer, as she took my order, poured my drink, and gave me the check. She ignored me the entire time but was friendly to everyone else. As an Asian female, I don’t appreciate nor tolerate discriminatory behavior and will not be back at this establishment.

I highly recommend Hamilton Hall. The food is amazing. I got the avocado french toast, and it was spectacular. It was hearty and filling and just enough to be satisfying without going overboard. The service is great, and they had plenty of options for whatever you are looking for. If you are in the area, it is definitely worth the visit!

For brunch, we ordered steak and eggs and a hamburger. We asked for med-rare. We got well done. One more person got caesar w chicken. Everything seemed average at best. I am guessing this restaurant gets better ratings because people are drinking. Our drinks were not enough to sway us. Server was super nice. Food was mediocre.

Given the timing of year and state of the world finding a outdoor heated dining spot was a challenge. We ended up here and man, BEST DECISION EVER! Food was amazing with huge portions, staff was incredible and the outdoor seating was toasty. The owner came and hung with us and couldnt have been a nicer guy. If you havent yet, you have to try this place.

Visited randomly with my boyfriend and absolutely loved it. The owner and bartender were extremely funny and welcoming. The drinks are also delicious, and I really felt them after only two! I definitely recommend this place and cant wait to check out their happy hour. Definitely a hidden gem in Harlem.

Ordred the brunch burger (includes bacon, cheddar, egg, LTO). It arrived w/o the cheese and bacon but w/ the onion I asked to leave it. Waitress was apologetic, but came back with a burger oozing grease. Quality of the beef was simply disgusting. Took 15 minutes to get a bloody mary, which seemed strange as the place wasnt crowded.

I honestly dont remember how much the food was. I was having such a good time! I do, however, remember that it was delicious. My bill was costly because I kept buying drink rounds at the bar.... I highly recommend this place.

Really nice place, good food and cocktails are on point. S

Love the whole atmosphere of the place and the fact that our office party was secluded was so cool !! The minus was that we didnt have our own bartender in the back but it was pleasant regardless !!

Great new-ish neighborhood spot. Delicious food, great drinks, and the staff is awesome. Gavin is such a sweetheart who will make you feel like youve known him your whole life. I super recommend this place!

Awesome place n service. They have a lovely patio you can actually play your won music. Erin is the best. She had a smile n great energy all the time.

I’m a regular! This was my first time ordering on Seamless and I got the burger! It’s NYE and my food arrived perfect! They can get all my takeout money! When this space opened as a local I felt some kind of way because they took half of the space away from Matto! The cafe next door! Then I had Thanksgiving here with a friend! The food isn’t average or sub par! It’s comparable to a Michelin restaurant I ate at in Germany! The chef is young and up and coming! Lucky to have scooped him and even better for us locals! The bartender is now a warm acquaintance and with the neighborhood changing so rapidly, us regulars now gather outside at Hamilton Hall! Gavin is a great bartender, China a wonderful waitress, and AJ a future top chef! Mickey is a great owner serving guests on holiday or outside on a cool covid night! The Caesar salad is bomb! A dressing that compliments! The butternut squash soup tastes like autumn! Seeds and creme frache! Thanksgiving was a pre fix menu and honestly I anticipated the worst but was surprised to have amazing course finished with a pecan pie that rivals Baton Rouge Louisiana! And I just ordered the burger! Perfection! I have no complaints! I can’t wait until covid subsides to get a full affect of the interior! Try some of their classics too! Hot toddy does the trick if you’re out late parlaying! I’m so happy to write this review! Support small business! They need us now more than ever!

Hesitant to share this low key spot for fear of not getting a table anymore, but they deserve notice for outstanding gastropub food (confit wings w/ housemade sauces and pickled vegetables; a killer fried chicken sandwich, etc...)Great owners and staff, and once they open up inside Ill certainly be visiting way too often, beautiful inside and with a long long lease, theyre here to stay. Such a welcome addition to the neighborhood!

The best place Ive found in NY. Nice selection of draft beers, great service and wonderful atmosphere

Amazing drinks and service

I found this place on the Seated app and decided to check it out. Upon arriving the owner(?), Mickey, asked us if we wanted to be seated by the bar where the game was playing or somewhere quiet. We elected somewhere quiet since we were not into sports.We ordered the Oysters, Shepherds Pie, and Sears Salmon. Mickey recommended the Coops Island and Great Gunn because we advised we like big oyster. Mickey gave us an additional 2 oysters because he said the remaining GG and CI oysters werent as big (BIG PLUS!~). I would definitely recommend the Alpine Oysters (its on the happy hour Mon-Fri 4-8). The Coops Island and Great Gunns followed in taste respectively.I dont usually order Shepherds Pie but something about the old fashion all American decor made me want to try it. It was very delicious, best one Ive had (though I havent had many). Only caveat was the portion wasnt super filling but the taste more than makes up for it. The Seared Salmon on the order hand looked hearty and tasted very yummy.Overall, great experience and Im glad I tried them out :)

Happening upon a live band there was the only redeemer. Overpriced Beer, oddly shaped pitchers that nobody wants and a server that had the audacity to demand a tip. Its hit or miss.

I just stopped in for a non alcoholic beer to kill a bit of time. handsome place. I liked the bartender. Good fin in the neighborhood.

Really cozy atmosphere, beautiful bar, very friendly and professional. The appetizer menu is spot on. Best deviled eggs anywhere. An oasis in Hamilton Heights

Great food and drinks. Just had one of the best old fashioned here. But the highlight was having one of the best Shepards piei n NYC. Boy have I missed it

The food wasn’t as good as I expected, however the energy and vibes were so great. There was a nice trivia game and everyone was interacting.The drinks were 8/10 but the ESPRESSO MARTINI was 10/10. I high recommend that.

I ordered risotto and they gave me rice.

This place is always delicious and the food has stayed consistently good! It’s so hard to get that sometimes, but the few times I have been here, the food stayed exactly the same! I really like it!

Whenever I am here for bingo, Payphone is always on my bingo card. Anyways…the service here is awesome and the food is tasty

Delicious food and drinks.. must try.

Truffle mushroom pizzaFried chicken sandwichWine and food were awesome! Great food and service.

Fantastic addition to the neighborhood. Gavin and Chynna are always a killer team to get you anything you could need. And Tasha makes a fantastic drink. Also I love having a local place with live music, especially after a year of listening through headphones. Glad to make this a regular spot.

Great Bar

I really like the place. The staff and food are great.Great selection of beers.

Great bar or restaurant. Very accommodating. Nice jazz on sat night. Go hang in a chill neighborhood spot.

Great service. Experienced Bartenders. Delicious food. Old charm decor with modern touches

Friendly service

A great neighborhood spot, food is very good and the pub atmosphere is in the air, service is excellent

Love that theres a limited food menu from 11PM to 1AM and late night live music.

Was there for a wedding. Food was amazing. Service was great. Had a great time.

A local favorite of mine, fantastic food and amazing service. Highly recommend!!!

Such fun trivia, such good food, great servers, and good vibes!

Couldnt sleep 😴, found a great late night Irish pub haunt. They have the basics and its a chill place.

Very tasty spot. Awesome food and drinks.

Chill sports bar with a robust food menu

Considering restaurants alike in neighborhood, the ambiance was mediocre, unsure if it were me & a friend, constantly reminding waitress for items ordered and extras.!With tip (Sunday Brunch) $44/person. I’ve been to comparable places but with a lot better service & food overall. Would not recommend brunch here

Beautifully designed bar. Classic, classy, and comfortable. Just what we need. Bravo!

Brought a group of 14 here for a birthday party and had a great time! I booked ahead so they had a nice big space reserved for us in the back, and our server Rachael took great care of us and even did separate checks which made our lives much easier. Great food and good happy hour deals, will definitely be back soon!

The service and drinks are always good.

Cool, chill vibe. Friendly bartender and crowd. Would definitely go back. Want to try the food.

Trivia night...was fun but we lost by far...😆 🤣 😂

I didnt like the Hamilton burger was to drying

Great bar and restaurant with better than expected food.

Freshest Guinness in town along with being perfectly pulled. The food and ambiance are like a friendly neighborhood pub run by your best friend. Go and enjoy, theres even live music 🎶 on the weekends.

Friendly bartender, nice mixed drinks and chill vibe!

One of my favorite places to go to in this neighborhood.Fabulous crowd & serviceFabulous food always clean and HIGH qualityExcellent serviceTrivia is so much fun I have to try trivia !

Entire meal (eggs, bacon and homefries) was barely warm. Food was not made to order, which is odd bc only two tables were occupied. Overall, the meal size felt stingy for $15. Regardless, I didnt finish it.

Nice place for first date, family dinner or group gathering. Moderately fun lighting, all venues of music, moderate to seeing drinks, nice portions of food (most ppl take ½ thier food home).I 💜 Hamilton Halls steak sandwich.

Great place. Best food options for the area. 8 TV. Outdoor seating. Grown up spot. Bartenders very friendly. Owner very welcoming.

Happy with service.

A great addition to the neighborhood. Cant wait for live music to begin once indoor dining comes back! My fiance had the burger and it was OUTSTANDING. My only wish is for a couple more light/healthy options on the menu. But the food here is definitely way better than your average pub food!

Lovely place to have a beer and the Guinness is fresh. A rarity in NYC. The bartenders Gavin and Natasha are top notch humans making the bar feel like a home away from home.

It is a good spot for a nice, relaxed drink and meal with your friends. Music is not too loud, perfect to chat. Several options for beer and wines. Good food menu with a twist to dishes example the chicken pot pie is deconstructed. I would say this is a mildly expensive place (meal starting at $20 ish) compared to other place in the neighbourhood. But it has a unique, charming vibe.

Come to Hamilton Hall. Gorgeous bar and the best staff around.

I come here and get work done on my laptop. Just discovered it and so far so good. I get the charcuterie board and a margarita.

Food was fresh...bartender was knowledgeable and friendly..music was mixed , a Lil of everything which I really enjoyed.

I like fresh salad? It looks like someone bit all the good parts of the cucumber and threw it on my salad. I tried but I just couldn’t eat it. You can even see teeth marks in it! How disgusting. They offered to refund me but why would I want a second chance at a disgusting restaurant. They hire kids I know but please supervise them. I don’t to be a victim of a juvenile prank. This is disgusting!

This place is great! Owner and staff are super friendly

Always excellent! I love the atmosphere! The bar is beautiful with multiple big screens. The drinks are delicious and the service is superb! I highly recommend!

Chicke pot pie was a very small portion.

Great food, great jazz Saturday with the Marc Devine trio. Best burger in the City

We sat outside. Hot wings were good

First time coming here today after being turned down at The Grange for not having a reservation ---- this is my new favorite place! I ordered the Avocado toast (same order as The Grange) and not only is the portion bigger, its so much better! We also ordered the chips and guac-- so much delicious guac with pico de gallo on top! The sangria was to die for!!!!! I usually steer clear of sangrias because at most places its old fruits floating around in cheap wine --- not here!! It was delicious. They have a downstairs outside patio that is so nice and cozy. We met the owner and he was super cool. Our server Erin was wonderful: friendly, attentive...Again, NEW FAVORITE PLACE. Please come here and see for yourself!

This place has a great neighborhood feel. If you want to get to know the neighborhood...step inside!

Hamilton hall Is an awesome location! We were lucky to work a wedding at the restaurant and the space was gorgeous, food delicious, and staff super nice

A little diamond in the rough. The service was absolutely great. Thanks to Mickey & Natasha for a memorable evening.

Private seating in booth with heat and blanket. Good food and dessert. Childs menu. Awesome service!! 5 star 🌟 ✨ Covid19 SAFE!!

Its a kool low key spot for good vibes 😉

My go to spot uptown..Delicious food, super clean and a great friendly staff!!

Great service and food. Great live music too

Dope spot for karaoke

Attentive staff, great brunch.

Long and nice bar, good selection of beer. Tried the cheese platter and.it was so filling I didnt order an entree. I guess it was for the and I had it all lolThe story of my life- if I like it a loooootI wont share it. If I like it a little or average Ill share. Haha

Loved the margherita pizza here!! Wonderful friendly staff as well

Great place

Coll jazz jam Sunday

Bartender seemed like she was in a bad mood.

I love the brunch on the weekends.

Happy to find a traditional Irish breakfast.

Live Irish music on St. Patricks Day. Standard pub food and Guinness.

Damm good burger! And Guinness!

Beautiful location with awesome food and drinks

Good food

Go to hear the Sunday night jam!

Nice place ...... me encantoo

Very nice restaurant nice staff

Excellent brunch 👌

Great service and food

Amazing

Awesome bar!

Nice bartenders

Very disappointing place.

Good vibes

Beautiful place

Nice Neighborhood

The place was a surprise. Nice environment and good service. The food was of a high standard (the chicken with mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts was delicious), the beers were good with a wide choice. Adequate price.

Excellent place, quiet, good atmosphere, excellent presentation of its preparations....

We just drank something here, didnt eat anything. But the menu has a lot to offer and we would like to eat something here. The atmosphere is great, like in a real American bar.

Great bar/pub in Harlem. Good food and excellent service. Outside the tourist channels, only Yankee. Jazz music in the evening. Well done

Bad service, they leave people waiting for a long time, very low